Florida’s proposed K-12 science standards raise questions about evolution and climate change 


A school classroom sits empty after classes end (Adobe Stock / Fokasu Art)

Florida is rewriting its K-12 science standards for the first time in nearly two decades, with proposed changes drawing concerns over how students will learn about evolution, climate change and other scientific concepts going forward. 

These changes could affect K-12 students by introducing a restructured science curriculum that limits mentions of evolution and human-caused climate change.

The new standards could also affect teachers and families as they navigate new educational expectations and concerns about whether students will be adequately prepared if they pursue careers in biology, medicine or other science-related fields.

Florida’s Department of Education is reviewing revisions and released and updated list on Oct. 23 to the state’s “Benchmarks for Excellent Student Thinking (B.E.S.T.) science standards,” which are what establishes expectations for what students should learn at each grade level. These standards are still under review. 

Standardized tests such as the MCAT and TEAS rely heavily on foundational biology and other scientific concepts. Kindergarten through second grade would begin using the updated standards during the 2028-29 school year, followed by older grade levels in 2029-30. 

For future educators, science standards can shape what students are exposed to in the classroom. Shawnice Stewart, a junior elementary education student at Florida A&M University, said science standards are important because they determine what students learn and can help build a foundation for their future education. 

“Changing the standards doesn’t just affect what students learn in that moment, but it can affect what they’re prepared for later on too,” Stewart said. 

Stewart said students need a strong science foundation because they may not know what career they want to pursue while they are in elementary or high school. She said students should still be exposed to accurate scientific information and develop curiosity about science. 

“You still want to make sure they’re learning accurate information and developing that curiosity about science,” Stewart said. 

Stewart also said changes to science standards could affect teachers because they may have to adjust their lesson plans and what they teach in the classroom. She said students could miss important information that may be needed later if they pursue fields such as biology, nursing or medicine. 

Deja Hayes, a second-year student at Galen College of Nursing, also expressed concerns about how changes to K-12 science standards could affect students interested in pursuing careers in healthcare. 

Hayes said science education provides students with foundational knowledge that prepares them for college-level coursework and future careers in nursing and medicine. She emphasized the importance of biology as a foundation for understanding science, along with anatomy and physiology as essential subjects for students entering the medical field. 

“Science education is crucial for students who want to enter the medical field as it provides them with the fundamental knowledge they need to succeed in college and beyond,” Hayes said. 

Hayes said students should develop a solid understanding of basic science concepts before entering college to help prepare them for the academic expectations of healthcare programs. 

Tajunique Moses, an afterschool group leader at a local elementary school, also expressed concerns about how changes to education could affect students’ academic preparation. Moses said she feels education levels could be pushed back even further because standardized testing already places a strong emphasis on math and reading. 

“These setbacks are clear indicators that the proposed changes the F.D.O.E. are making wouldn’t in fact help further the education of K-12 students, but in fact make it harder for them to be educated in the most needed career fields today, which are in science-based industries,” Moses said. According to the Florida Department of Education Standards Review website list grades k-5 released a second round of revisions to the public for the B.E.S.T/STARS science standards and documents. 

As Florida considers and continues revisions to its science standards, educators, students and families continue to raise questions about how the changes could affect classroom instruction and students’ preparation for future academic and professional opportunities.

Leave a Reply